Lesson 07.4
Launch emails that convert
Five emails, sent in the right order with the right subject line, will sell more than any single perfect one.
The five-email sequence
Email 1, early access: 'You're in first — doors open to you now' sent the moment the sales page goes live to the waitlist. Email 2, 24 hours later: 'Here's exactly what's inside March's envelope', heavy on photos.
Email 3, public open day: 'Doors are open to everyone' with a plain subject that doesn't need a gimmick. Email 4, mid-week reminder: 'A few spots left' only if genuinely true — never fabricate scarcity.
Email 5, last call: 'Closing tonight at 9pm ET' with the exact time and timezone stated twice — once in the subject, once in the first line. Each email in the sequence should be readable on its own, in case someone only opens one of the five.
- Email 1: early access, sent to waitlist only
- Email 2: what's inside, photo-heavy
- Email 3: public open, plain subject line
- Email 4: honest scarcity reminder
- Email 5: last call, exact closing time
Subject lines that get opened
Specific beats clever. 'March's envelope is open — 100 spots' outperforms 'Something exciting is here' in almost every test we've seen from members. Numbers, dates and the word 'open' or 'closing' do the work.
Keep subject lines under 50 characters so they don't truncate on mobile, where most of your list will read them. Avoid ALL CAPS and excess punctuation — spam filters and readers both flag it.
Test one variable at a time if your email platform allows split sends: try a number-led subject against a question-led one on a small slice of the list, then send the winner to the rest. It only costs a few minutes and often lifts opens by five to ten points.
Timing and cadence
Space the five emails across the open-and-close window, not evenly across the full two weeks — teaser content lives on social, the sales emails belong in the final 5-6 days when someone's ready to decide.
Send the final email on the morning of the close, not the night before. People act closer to a deadline, and a morning email gives them the whole day to act on it.
What to do with non-openers
Around the reminder stage, resend email 3 or 4 with a fresh subject line only to people who didn't open the first version. This alone can add another 20-30% in opens on top of the original send without annoying anyone who already read it.
Don't resend to people who clicked but didn't buy using the same subject — a slightly different angle, like leading with a member quote instead of the offer, gives them a new reason to look again.
Keep a simple log of open and click rates from each launch so you can compare sequences over time. A subject line that got 40% opens in March is worth reusing with small tweaks in June, rather than starting from a blank page every launch.
Writing the email body once the subject is chosen
Open with the same promise from the subject line in the first sentence, then get to a photo fast — most recipients decide to keep reading based on the image, not the second paragraph of text. Keep the body to a few short paragraphs and one clear button.
Use a single call-to-action button per email rather than several competing links. 'Join now' repeated once, clearly, converts better than a button, then a text link, then another button all pointing to the same page.
Worth remembering
- Five emails beat one, sent in early-access to last-call order
- Specific numbers in subject lines outperform clever copy
- Only use scarcity language if it's literally true
- Send the last-call email the morning of, not the night before
Do this before the next lesson
Draft all five subject lines today, then write the emails to match them.